7 carriers raised and 22 carriers cut Colorado auto rates in 2026. The fastest way to stop overpaying is to compare carriers for your ZIP — the cheapest options in Colorado are below.
Cheapest car insurance carriers in Colorado right now
Estimated annual premiums for a standard profile, cheapest first — Colorado averages about $3,264/yr. The spread between carriers is wide, so shopping is how you beat a rate hike.
| # | Carrier | Est. annual | vs avg |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | USAA | $1,865/yr | Save $1,004 |
| 2 | Travelers | $2,547/yr | Save $322 |
| 3 | Root Insurance | $2,701/yr | Save $168 |
| 4 | State Farm | $2,777/yr | Save $92 |
| 5 | Progressive | $2,833/yr | Save $36 |
| 6 | GEICO | $2,904/yr | +$35 |
| 7 | The Hartford | $3,259/yr | +$390 |
| 8 | Kemper | $3,374/yr | +$505 |
| 9 | Safeco | $3,468/yr | +$599 |
| 10 | Nationwide | $3,520/yr | +$651 |
Carriers that cut Colorado rates more than once
A single filing undersells a carrier that keeps cutting. These carriers cut the same book two or more times, and the cuts stack: State Farm’s 2 filings add up to about −11.6% on 1,174,505 policyholders. Repeated cuts usually mean a carrier is pricing to win new customers — worth a quote if you haven’t checked it lately.
| Carrier | Cuts, in order | Combined | Policyholders |
|---|---|---|---|
| Country Financial COUNTRY Preferred Insurance Company | −8.0% (Sep 10, 2025) → −10.0% (Mar 27, 2026) SERFF CFPC-134576315, CFPC-134761648 | −17.2% | 8,223 |
| State Farm State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | −4.0% (Jul 29, 2025) → −7.8% (Dec 15, 2025) SERFF SFMA-134532998, SFMA-134702926 | −11.6% | 1,174,505 |
| American Family American Family Insurance Company | −2.4% (Aug 22, 2025) → −8.3% (Jan 9, 2026) → 0.0% (Oct 1, 2026) SERFF AMFC-134597744, AMFC-134763393, AMFC-135031630 | −10.5% | 67,341 |
| Shelter Shelter Mutual Insurance Company | −2.4% (Dec 8, 2025) → −6.0% (May 13, 2026) SERFF SHEL-134676453, SHEL-134848258 | −8.2% | 47,822 |
| Progressive Progressive Direct Insurance Company | −3.0% (May 30, 2025) → −4.8% (Oct 31, 2025) SERFF PRGS-134483202, PRGS-134710552 | −7.7% | 354,385 |
Combined = the filings compounded on one company’s book, counting only changes already in effect. Statewide averages; your change varies.
Carriers that raised Colorado rates in 2026
| Carrier | Change | Effective | Affected | % of brand | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Auto-Owners Owners Insurance Company | +3.4% | Jun 20, 2025 | 10,772 | 85.5% | SERFF #AOIC-134543973 ↗ |
| Bristol West | +1.3% | Aug 15, 2025 | 64,177 | — | SERFF #BRWS-134618032 ↗ |
| Farmers Economy Fire & Casualty Company | +3.0% | Dec 19, 2025 | 9,724 | 24.2% | SERFF #FAIG-134760202 ↗ |
| National General Integon National Insurance Company | +0.8% | Feb 5, 2026 | 16,502 | 69.4% | SERFF #GMMX-134791750 ↗ |
| Bristol West | +7.6% | Mar 6, 2026 | 49,552 | — | SERFF #BRWS-134848458 ↗ |
| Liberty Mutual Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company | +2.3% | May 30, 2026 | 28,990 | 49.5% | SERFF #LBPM-134929216 ↗ |
| The Hartford Hartford Insurance Company of the Southeast | +5.0% | Jul 9, 2026 | 10,561 | — | SERFF #HART-134868697 ↗ |
Carriers that cut Colorado rates in 2026
| Carrier | Change | Effective | Affected | % of brand | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive Progressive Direct Insurance Company | −3.0% | May 30, 2025 | 345,517 | 74.4% | SERFF #PRGS-134483202 ↗ |
| Kemper Financial Indemnity Company | −4.0% | Jul 3, 2025 | 11,374 | — | SERFF #UTRN-134591314 ↗ |
| State Farm State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | −4.0% | Jul 29, 2025 | 1,152,647 | 97.6% | SERFF #SFMA-134532998 ↗ |
| American Family | −2.4% | Aug 22, 2025 | 67,341 | — | SERFF #AMFC-134597744 ↗ |
| Country Financial COUNTRY Preferred Insurance Company | −8.0% | Sep 10, 2025 | 8,223 | 82.7% | SERFF #CFPC-134576315 ↗ |
| Nationwide Nationwide General Insurance Company | −5.0% | Oct 18, 2025 | 6,516 | 27.0% | SERFF #NWPP-134667683-2 ↗ |
| Progressive Progressive Direct Insurance Company | −4.8% | Oct 31, 2025 | 354,385 | 74.4% | SERFF #PRGS-134710552 ↗ |
| Shelter | −2.4% | Dec 8, 2025 | 47,822 | — | SERFF #SHEL-134676453 ↗ |
| State Farm State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | −7.8% | Dec 15, 2025 | 1,174,505 | 97.6% | SERFF #SFMA-134702926 ↗ |
| Allstate Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company | −5.7% | Dec 20, 2025 | 5,292 | 2.7% | SERFF #ALSE-134679055 ↗ |
| Allstate | −4.3% | Dec 20, 2025 | 9,583 | 4.9% | SERFF #ALSE-134679258 ↗ |
| Allstate Allstate Indemnity Company | −0.7% | Dec 20, 2025 | 3,244 | 1.7% | SERFF #ALSE-134681921 ↗ |
| American Family | −8.3% | Jan 9, 2026 | 62,396 | — | SERFF #AMFC-134763393 ↗ |
| Farmers Truck Insurance Exchange | −0.1% | Feb 16, 2026 | 30,531 | 75.8% | SERFF #FARM-134841662 ↗ |
| Root | −3.2% | Feb 20, 2026 | 28,230 | — | SERFF #CLIN-134847318 ↗ |
| Liberty Mutual American Economy Insurance Company | −6.0% | Mar 5, 2026 | 21,703 | 38.2% | SERFF #LBPM-134848938 ↗ |
| National General Integon National Insurance Company | −2.0% | Mar 12, 2026 | 18,695 | 69.4% | SERFF #GMMX-134857802 ↗ |
| Country Financial COUNTRY Preferred Insurance Company | −10.0% | Mar 27, 2026 | 8,093 | 82.7% | SERFF #CFPC-134761648 ↗ |
| GEICO GEICO Advantage Insurance Company | −4.7% | Apr 24, 2026 | 21,550 | 8.9% | SERFF #GECC-134903984 ↗ |
| Shelter | −6.0% | May 13, 2026 | 46,528 | — | SERFF #SHEL-134848258 ↗ |
| Allstate Allstate North American Insurance Company | −5.0% | May 15, 2026 | 39,377 | 17.5% | SERFF #ALSE-134861443 ↗ |
| USAA USAA Casualty Insurance Company | −1.0% | Aug 7, 2026 | 92,966 | 36.0% | SERFF #USAA-134924660 ↗ |
Are you actually getting the new rate?
Approved changes are statewide averages, and a cut usually reaches new buyers first — existing customers often don’t see it until their next renewal, if at all. The only way to know you’re on the best current price is to re-shop.
Filing figures are filed/approved statewide averages from each state’s Department of Insurance; rankings are directional estimates. “Affected” counts are policyholders or insured vehicles as stated in each filing. Your individual rate varies by risk profile. Each filing links to its source. Not a quote.