BoringRate

Tools

Rate ComparisonRank every carrier for your ZIP Auto Coverage CalculatorFind the right coverage level Renters Coverage CalculatorHow much renters coverage you need Home Coverage CalculatorDwelling, liability & add-ons Carrier ComparisonHead-to-head any two carriers

Research

Akron Albany Albuquerque Allentown Anchorage Asheville Atlanta Austin Bakersfield Baltimore Baton Rouge Billings Birmingham Boise Boston Buffalo Burlington, VT Charleston, WV Charlotte Chattanooga Cheyenne Chicago Cincinnati Cleveland Colorado Springs Columbia, SC Columbus Dallas–Ft. Worth Dayton Denver Des Moines Detroit El Paso Fargo Fresno Grand Rapids Greensboro Greenville, SC Hartford Honolulu Houston Indianapolis Jackson, MS Jacksonville Kansas City Knoxville Las Vegas Lexington Little Rock Los Angeles Louisville Madison Manchester, NH Memphis Miami Milwaukee Minneapolis–St. Paul Nashville New Jersey New Orleans New York City Norfolk Oklahoma City Omaha Orlando Pensacola Philadelphia Phoenix Pittsburgh Portland Portland, ME Providence Raleigh–Durham Reno Richmond Riverside–IE Rochester Sacramento Salt Lake City San Antonio San Diego San Jose Savannah Seattle Sioux Falls Spokane St. Louis Syracuse Tampa Tucson Tulsa Washington, D.C.Wichita Wilmington, DE Worcester

National carriers

USAA Military & family GEICO Online shoppers State Farm Local agents Progressive High-risk & incidents Allstate Accident forgiveness Liberty Mutual New car replacement Farmers Full-service agents Nationwide Vanishing deductible Erie Mid-Atlantic & Midwest American Family Midwest families Amica Claims service Auto-Owners 26-state agent Travelers Homeowner bundles Safeco Independent agents The Hartford AARP & 50+ drivers Root Insurance Telematics · safe drivers AAA / CSAA Members & roadside

Regional & local

Texas Farm Bureau Texas only Georgia Farm Bureau Georgia only Tennessee Farm Bureau Tennessee only NC Farm Bureau North Carolina Kentucky Farm Bureau Kentucky only Louisiana Farm Bureau Louisiana only PEMCO WA & OR NJM Insurance NJ / CT / PA Wawanesa California only Mercury Insurance CA & 10 states Shelter Insurance 15-state Central MAPFRE Insurance Massachusetts NYCM Insurance New York only Alfa Insurance Southeast Country Financial Midwest

Rankings & data

National Carrier Market Share — who controls the U.S. market State-by-State Rate Rankings — avg. premium + top carriers per state

About

Methodology — how we collect and rank rate data

BoringRate · Carrier Compare

Compare any two carriers.

Pick two from the 12 carriers below. We'll pull up a side-by-side on price, complaint ratios, and driver profiles.

Pick a carrier to start

1

GEICO

1

State Farm

1

Progressive

1

Allstate

1

Nationwide

1

Travelers

1

Farmers

1

USAA

1

Liberty Mutual

1

Safeco

1

The Hartford

1

Root

1

AAA / CSAA

Compare →

Popular comparisons

GEICO vs State Farm

The two biggest carriers head to head

GEICO vs Progressive

Online pricing vs telematics focus

State Farm vs Progressive

Agent-driven vs digital

GEICO vs Allstate

Price leader vs accident forgiveness

Progressive vs Allstate

High-risk friendly vs bundling focus

Cheapest national vs cheapest military

CSAA vs Travelers

Claims handling, rates & availability compared

Compare rates

Cheapest car insurance for your ZIP

Rank every carrier by estimated price for your exact ZIP and profile — in seconds, no calls.

Coverage calculator

Not sure how much you need?

See what to buy and what to skip — and how each choice changes your price.

Help me choose my coverage options →

Compare auto rates →